
I'm going to dedicate this entry to Erin ‘Nifkin’ Altman.
Erin, alongside my two other Hamilton girlfriends Katie and Jess, was the literal highlight of my college experience. Anything that happened outside the presence of those three was completely secondary... and that includes everything I learned in class, (Sorry dad, I know that’s not what you want to hear.) Though the four of us have remained friends since graduation, we don't get together nearly as often as I would like. Over the past couple of months, however, Erin and I have been making it a point to talk and spend as much time together as our conflicting schedules will allow; reinforcing how grateful I am to have her in my life. I’m sitting here with my back to an open window, the rain outside hitting me in the head- I’m hoping the Gods of Eloquence will assist me in constructing a sentence that won’t leave me sounding corny or trite. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look like that’s going to happen, so here's what I can say, Nifkin- I love you. I love you for so many reasons- and maybe some time I’ll get into them all... But right now, I love you for being the most supportive, patient, and wonderful friend I could have possibly asked for through my descent into dreaded girly-hell. You have been a constant support through the bitching, whining, and over analyzing of every little thing; you never get bored of me, you never get drained- you are the best.
I guess now would be a good time for a little background. According to the laws of Kabbalah, everyone who comes into your life has been put there to push your buttons in a specific way in order to teach you something. It’s your individual responsibility to find out what that is, because if you do not then even if you manage to get rid of the horrible person who made you so unhappy someone worse (or at the very least equally horrible) will show up to take his/her place. I believe I said something on this subject in regards my college non-boyfriend Sean. I mentioned that though he has been out of my life for seven years and dead for nearly three, the evil that was in him continues to show up in my life in the form of other relationships. Since I have been out of college, I can think of five relationships, (or more accurately non-relationships) wherein I’ve essentially found myself dating Sean’s ghost. For the sake of brevity as well as my own sanity, I’m not going to go into gory detail about them all. I will say though, that the common threads were dishonesty, selfishness and at times, blatant meanness. The only difference is that Sean was 100% Irish and the rest were all Jewish, Italian, or some combination thereof.
Up until a couple of days ago, I was involved with a man (if you can even call him that) who when looking from the outside in, I had no business with. It's a running joke among my friends that I have the most bizarre/abominable taste in men. But as I said, there was definitely a karmic reason why this person, who for the sake of privacy and protecting the innocent will remain nameless, showed up in my life. THAT is where my Nifkin comes in. Nifkin, by the way, is not actually her middle name, it's just what we call eachother.
Erin and I, both philosophy majors, have had countless discussions on the topic of relationships and interpersonal trust. We are pretty much polar opposites in regards to the ways that we view and conduct our relationships. Erin has had three serious, long-term relationships over the last 11 years... I've had about a hundred what can only be described as silly, short-term ones. And we have both spent so much time totally miserable, why? We've dissected the subject ad nauseam and I think what we’ve come up with might be worth listening to...
There is a term in philosophy called skepticism, which is the idea that nothing is for certain. For example, how does one know that the floor is going to be there to meet your foot every time you take a step? You don't is the answer- but you have to just kinda live as though you are sure because well, what other choice is there?
When it comes to personal relationships and love, however, it gets tricky because some people believe there is a choice... What I'm referring to is the thing that some snooping while others consider merely doing their due-dilligence. I never really understood the logic that supports snooping around in my boyfriend's stuff or checking behind his back to confirm his word. Obviously, the goal of the snooper is self-protection; but protection against whom? Your partner? Aren't you supposed to be on the same side? Isn't that the whole point of coupling off? To avoid isolation and aloneness?
That's always been my arguement, anyway, that snooping, aka going through your partner’s things, asking questions that aren't your business, fact-checking, or any other display of doubt in your partner is never okay. I say this because I truly believe if you cannot trust your partner, than you do not love him, plain and simple. You may think you do, but love, according to me at least, isn't a a feeling; it's an action. To Love means to put that person's needs ahead of your own; and by needs, I mean emotional as well as the tangible. So how could it be okay to put your need for certainty ahead of his need for respect? That’s the opposite of love; its selfishness.
Even if it does come from low self-esteem, it's still wrong. If you believe that you aren't lovable, why would you ever believe someone who tells you that you are? You'll convince yourself that that person is a liar; and every move you make will be motivated by your need to prove yourself right, thus making the whole thing about you- not him. What kind of relationship is that?
To bring the floor metaphor back for a second, I guess I would liken it to taking a hammer and pounding the wood 60 times before taking a step. That’s what you’re doing when you don’t trust your partner. Eventually, even the strongest floor is going to crack. And when you do fall through it, who is to blame? The floor, or you and your stupid hammer?
Being someone who has spend 90% of her relationship history playing the role of the floor... it's very easy for me to say 'You and your stupid hammer' are to blame. Unfortunately, everyone, even the floor has to take responsibility for his or her own experience. So what if you're the floor in this scenario? What if you're the one who's constantly getting struck by your partner's fictitious hammer of doubt?
Obviously a floor is inanimate and an object in this scenario, so let's flip the metaphor around and say that you are now the person who has looked down and seen that this floor is FULL of deep gashes that you did NOT put there and the wood is rotting? Do you continue to step? Most people would not.
Sadly, I am not most people... Back to nameless dude. How can I describe him? Well, for one thing, he was closed. The kind of guy who would share very little about himself in conversation, always preferred to be the one asking the questions. Any time I tried to shift the focus onto him he would deflect the question and immediately return to his more favored role of information gatherer. There was a part of me that didn't mind the attention on me. I did, after all choose a career in airing my dirty laundry. Unfortunately, the interest was not genuine. It was a manipulative tool used to make me feel safe and appreciated while distracting me from the fact that he wasn't actually revealing anything about himself; a tactic came into play again when, for example, the question of exclusivity came up. He had no qualms whatsoever about asking me not to date or sleep with anyone else, but wouldn't commit himself one way or the other. He wanted me to invest in him but refused to invest anything back.
What's more, he would put words in my mouth- things I never said, or things I did say but he'd take them completely out of context and use them as evidence that I didn't like him.
Here is a kind of funny example to prove my point. He's a white guy but his balls, (you know, testicles) are very dark, kind makes his scrotum look like a bicycle seat. It's sort of a funny visual, when you think about it. Anyway, one time without thinking, I made a perfectly benign observation about the difference in color around that area of his body and completely flipped out. He jumped to the conclusion that I was criticising him, I wasn't- it was merely an observation. But he insisted that I thought he was a freak and I wasn't attracted him and sulked about it for days.
Another time, we were having sex and he started accusing me of only pretending to like his dick. I'm a little bit uncomfortable revealing this just it's so vulgar, but I will anyway just to illustrate the severity of the situation. He started yelling at me, literally, in the middle of sex that I wished his dick was 4 inches longer and 2 inches thicker, just like my old boyfriends (how he ever managed to find the dimensions of that guy's dick, I will never know) But he was certain. He meant it. He had convinced himself that that's what was going on inside my head and he hated me for it. There was literally nothing I could say or do to convince him otherwise. And any attempt I made would be twisted around and turned into further evidence toward his point. There's no reasoning with a fanatic...and when it came to this man's self-hatred he was downright fanatical. Any observations I made he would insist were insults; Any compliments I tried to give him he would spin into mockeries. I couldn't win; there was literally not a thing I could say or do to get him to abandon that mission and and allow himself to feel close to me.
I realize that all of these examples show what is, by my OWN definition, is the opposite of love. Which begs the question, WHAT is wrong with me. How could I, Knowing full well that this person did not love me (again, I'm speaking of love in terms of action not feeling; I have no idea how he felt and it hardly matters) continue to step on those cracked floorboards, rotted nearly all the way through? It's not as though I haven't seen the signs before. I know what a floor that's full of holes looks like and yet I keep stepping right into them!
I can blame this guy and the slew before him all I want but at the end of the day, I am the failure for not using what I've learned from the past and allowing myself to become involved with someone who was clearly a lost cause from the start. My self-esteem needs a serious overhaul and fast. Everyone yearns to connect and to love and I'm no exception- but unfortunately so few of us really know how. It's a myth that everyone deserves it; some people don't! That saying, "You can't love another until you love yourself..." it's an inconvenient truth if ever there was one, but it's the true nonetheless.
Nifkin... Thank you for helping me keep my sanity through this tough, but necessary learning experience. You're an incredible person and an incredible friend and my appreciation for you is immeasurable- but we both have our work cut out for us. I need to find some stable floors and you need to stop driving hammers into the one you're currently standing on. I love you and I hope you love you too.